NZ detains three German yachties in Bay of Islands for defying border ban

The yacht's crew have all tested negative for covid-19 since arriving in Opua. Image: RNZ/123RF

By RNZ News

Three German yachtsmen – two men and a woman – have been detained after arriving in the Bay of Islands, in breach of New Zealand’s covid-19 border restrictions.

Despite being denied permission to enter the country, the trio’s yacht, Anita, arrived in Opua on Friday afternoon.

Immigration officials are now arranging for the three people to be flown home.

Immigration NZ’s border and visa operations manager Peter Elms said the crew requested a border exemption from the Ministry of Health, which was refused.

“New Zealand’s border restrictions are in place for a very good reason – to help stop the spread of covid-19 and protect the health of New Zealand’s population.

“The action by these individuals to knowingly travel here without approval demonstrates a blatant disregard for New Zealand’s border restrictions.”

Attempting to breach the country’s border controls was a serious matter, Elms said.

Long-term consequences
He added that being refused entry may also have long-term consequences for the sailors – their visa waiver status for New Zealand may be suspended and it may affect their ability to travel to other countries.

A Ministry of Health spokesperson said in a statement the crew of the vessel had all been tested for covid-19 and those tests were negative. They had also been isolated on their vessel for more than 14 days.

The crew had applied for an exemption, after they had already sailed for New Zealand.

It was being sought on two grounds, humanitarian and bringing the vessel to New Zealand for repair.

Their application was declined because the Director-General of Health was not convinced the boat had a compelling need to come into the country.

The ministry has previously provided guidance to potential applicants that “humanitarian reasons” would be unlikely to include situations such as financial loss, or to vessels travelling mainly for pleasure or convenience such as tourists or “wintering over” to avoid the hurricane/cyclone season in the Pacific.

This position has been widely communicated to the maritime community, including those in the South Pacific, the spokesperson said.

Not ‘compelling humanitarian need’
“While there were aspects of the case that were unfortunate, these did not rise to the threshold of a compelling humanitarian need. As much as our country is known for its hospitality, New Zealand cannot become a maritime covid-19 safe haven for everyone in unfortunate circumstances.”

Foreign yachties seeking refuge in New Zealand from seasonal Pacific cyclones have been campaigning for the move for months.

A week ago the UK based Ocean Cruising Club received official notice that foreign yachts waiting to leave the Pacific will not be allowed in to New Zealand, and must now make alternative arrangements.

The club had been liaising with New Zealand immigration and maritime agencies to find a way that would allow up to 300 yachts to sail here on the seasonal cruising route.

The ocean cruising club was told that maritime border restrictions applied under the current Covid-19 public health response.

The letter from the Director General of Health said limited exemptions existed on the ban on foreign ships coming to New Zealand, including cargo and fishing vessels.

Permission could also be granted for ships to enter, if there was a compelling need such as refits, repairs or humanitarian reasons.

Two new covid-19 cases
New Zealand yesterday reported two new cases of covid-19 – one imported and one historical.

In a statement, the Health Ministry said there were no new cases in the community.

One of the cases was an imported case detected in a managed isolation facility and the other was a historical case detected during contact tracing.

The ministry said the imported case was a man in his 30s who had arrived in New Zealand on September 21 from Russia via the United Arab Emirates.

There are now 61 active cases in New Zealand – 30 imported cases and 31 community cases. There have been a total of 1475 cases of covid-19 in New Zealand.

This article is republished by the Pacific Media Centre under a partnership agreement with RNZ.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. What have COCID-19 exposed for all to see?
    Vengeful opportunistic nincompoop bureaucrats / public servants without relevant education and experience rule the world!
    This will cost NZ hundreds of thousands $$$ in lost goodwill and lost marine work-opportunities in boat servicing!

  2. allowing the America’s Cup to proceed is surely then a two faced approach. One rule forvthe super elite and one forcthe reat.

    • So. The yachties probaby saved for years to buy their boat..and set off on an adventure.They were caught out by the COVId crisis and were in a potentially dangerous situation, along with all the other boats stuck in the Pacific during the cyclone season. They have been isolated ans tested negative for COVID 19. They ask for help and are refused. Now they are being depprtes and will no doubt.lose their boat. What kind of world are we living in. Why are our ‘leaders’ so cruel. Humans should help one another, not abandon them in times of need. Shame in the NZ bureaucrats. I hope they have trouble sleeping at night but I suspect that won’t be a problem for these heartless people.
      If the Germans were wealthy they would be welcomed with open arms. How is rje Americas Cup is allowed to proceed. It is all about money.. If the Americas Cup participants refused to go to NZ unless Ihe government helps their fellow sailors I bet they would change their minds.

  3. what a disgusting bunch of mindless bureaucrats! it is simply unbelievable what some people will do when you give them a bit of authority!

Comments are closed.