Alastair Thompson: ‘Seismic shift’ in US policy over Syria stuns the pundits


Syria’s President Assad vows to ‘retake the whole country’. Video: AFP interview on France 24

OPINION: By Alastair Thompson

The news that the Russians (Sergei Lavrov) and Americans (John Kerry) have come to an understanding on the next steps in Syria is confounding the pundits today – and the instinct to cling to the previous narrative (Russians bombing civilians) is something the BBC is struggling with somewhat.

This BBC news report for example is being headlined as we speak on the televised news – at the top of bulletins – with the spoken headline “Pressure is mounting on the Russians over their bombing campaign in Syria”.

Whereas the real news is that the Americans appear to have turned against their Free Syrian Army allies and decided to throw in their towel with the Russians – which, if for real, is a seismic shift in the conflict. That said, it is also something the political voices in Washington have been hinting at for some time and that European voices have been calling for over months.

The lead story on the BBC website hints at the more complex goings on with a rare AFP interview with Assad in which the president says he plans to retake his entire country (most of which is at present outside his control), although he says he does expect it to take some considerable time.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and US Secretary of State John Kerry speak at a news conference in Munich, Germany.
“Progress made” … Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and US Secretary of State John Kerry speak at a news conference in Munich, Germany.

Assad talks of there being two tracks, negotiations and fighting terrorists which are proceeding in parallel.

Simultaneously (perhaps as a sideshow – but with an element of truth lurking within) a bunch of apocalyptic pundits are talking of WW III breaking out in the region, either between the Turks and the Russians to the north, or between the Saudis, Egyptians and the Russians in the south.

Turkey and Saudi will be doubtless livid with the US decision to negotiate with Assad and the Russians and will see this decision for what it is, a massive U-Turn in policy which leaves them both in a rather dangerous and difficult position.

Apocalyptic reports
Three apocalyptic reports on these developments can be read here:

  1. Mounting Evidence Putin Will Ignite WWIII
  2. Limited Nuclear War Within 18 days as Saudis (and Friends) mass 350,000 troops, 20,000 Tanks, 2,450 Planes, 460 Helicopters for Syria Invasion
  3. Putin Threatening WWIII over Turkey

These reports need to be taken with large quantities of salt. That said, the lead up to the breakthrough talks in Munich between Russia and the US has plenty of credible intrigue associated with it.

First on Wednesday, US General Steve Warren very publicly in a video press conference with media accused Russia of bombing two hospitals in Aleppo and precipitating a humanitarian crisis for Turkey (thousands of people fleeing Aleppo are on the Turkish border).

The following day a Russian general responded very publicly with an allegation that two US A-10s had bombed the hospitals, having flown in from Turkey to do so. This was very quickly followed by a report quoting General Warren – who made the original accusations, this time responding by email and telling a US military publication that the US hasn’t bombed Aleppo since 2014 and it’s all nonsense.

It would seem that the US military leadership have either rapidly changed their plan, or there is sunlight between the political and military leadership.

As for us plebs on the receiving end of the TV version of the news, any news anchors who continue to report the events of the past two days as “more pressure being put on Russia to stop bombing civilians” are somewhat missing the importance of what is really going on here.

And finally for people who are keen to see a Syrian/Russian view of what is going on in this conflict on a blow by blow basis, this YouTube channel is interesting.

Alastair Thompson is editor and publisher of the leading independent New Zealand online news website Scoop.

Prospect of Saudi incursion raises fears of a Syrian conflict without end

apr BBC map institute study 680wide
Map: BBC

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. An update:

    This is extraordinary. The fog of war or willfull blindness.

    The entire world is reporting on Russian PM Medvedev’s warnings of “Permanent War” and/or WW3 if the Saudis send troops into Syria. But not it would appear the US Media. Someone must have issued a memo.

    At this link there are four pages of stories about Medvedev’s remarks which were reported first in Germany >> <> and here both of which concludes with this correction.

    “This story has been corrected to remove the words ‘new world war’ which were a mistranslation.”

    It seems particularly odd that the warnings from the Russians don’t make it into this story >> << Congress skeptical of increased Saudi commitment to ISIS fight in Syria, a @PowerPost exclusive intended as a briefing for Washington insiders. It is conceivable that the story predated this. But still very very odd.

Comments are closed.